Bruno Fernandes Backs Carrick’s Call to Drop Him After Roma Comeback
Michael Carrick's decision to drop his captain has been endorsed by the player himself. After Manchester United came from 2-0 down to beat Roma 3-2 in the UEFA Champions League league phase at Old Trafford on Tuesday night, Bruno Fernandes said his manager was right to put him on the bench last month, even if it was a punishment for his public criticism of United's tactics. BBC Sport reported it was the first time Fernandes had spoken to the media since being dropped.
“Bruno: Right to bench me after criticism of Man United tactics”
— ESPN FC (@ESPNsoccer), 3 November 2026
The decision
After United's previous Champions League match, a 4-1 defeat at Como, Fernandes blamed Carrick for the side's lack of pressing in a post-match interview, according to The Independent. Carrick responded by leaving him as an unused substitute for the next match, a 3-0 Premier League defeat at Bournemouth. Fernandes was restored to the side for the Premier League defeat by Chelsea, and against Roma he converted a twice-taken 58th-minute penalty that started the comeback before two goals from Matheus Cunha completed it, as The Guardian reported.
Why Fernandes says it was right
Speaking to Amazon Prime after the match, Fernandes said: “It's been tough, there's been a lot of speculation in the media. A lot of lies around many things that have happened between me and the manager, that we have cleared the air, then after that the manager took the decision to put me on the bench because I'm not performing. That's fair.”
He added: “Everyone thought that was a punishment for the words that I had. And, if it was, it was right. The manager is the one who makes the decisions. It doesn't change the belief I have of the manager and the staff and every player in this club.”
That matters for Carrick. A manager who drops his captain for speaking out risks losing the dressing room; instead, the captain has publicly backed the authority behind the call and responded with his best display of the season, according to ESPN.
Still under pressure
The win ended a run of nine matches without a victory, but it does not settle Carrick's position. United sit 17th in the Premier League with one win from their opening nine games, and BBC Sport reported that Carrick had been widely expected to be sacked after the Bournemouth defeat before the board decided he deserved a chance to turn things around. Carrick was given a two-year contract after winning 12 of his 17 games in charge last season.
Fernandes rejected the idea that the result was about one man. “We don't need to save anyone's job,” he said. “The club needed that win, the players needed that win.” Youri Tielemans was more direct when asked the same question: “That's a different question. The only thing we can do is stick behind him, fight for him and fight for the club.”
For now, the selection call that looked like a gamble a fortnight ago has the captain's public approval and a Champions League win attached to it. Whether it buys Carrick time depends on what follows in the Premier League.
What we reported next
- Manchester United confirm Mauricio Pochettino as head coach after Carrick exit
- Manchester United confirm Michael Carrick has left as head coach
- Manchester United reach a framework deal with Pochettino as Carrick's job is reviewed
Background
More from Champions League and the Team Selection section.
Sources
- ESPN FC on X
- ESPN: Bruno Fernandes says Carrick was right to drop him
- BBC Sport: Man Utd 3-2 Roma, Fernandes on Carrick's future
- The Independent: Fernandes admits Carrick was right to drop him
- The Guardian: 'I wasn't performing'
Spotted an error? See our corrections policy.
The Decide Football briefing
The biggest managerial decisions from across world football, by email. Free, and you can unsubscribe at any time.
Carrick's Shea Lacey Substitution Turns Manchester United's Champions League Comeback Against Roma
Manchester United confirm Mauricio Pochettino as head coach after Carrick exit
Manchester United confirm Michael Carrick has left as head coach
Manchester United reach a framework deal with Pochettino as Carrick's job is reviewed
Arteta defends Declan Rice’s full 90 after Slavia Prague
Iraola Defends Five Changes After Liverpool Lose 3-2 at Fenerbahçe in the Champions League
Danks Faces Neuer and Olise Calls for Bayern’s Atlético Champions League Trip
Flick Benches Cubarsí and Koundé Against Villarreal and Moves Frenkie de Jong Into His Back Four